Seriously, This Hipster Thing Has Gone Too Far

Lately I’ve seen that several blogs I follow are publishing articles about hipsters. While I’m generally annoyed by the whole hipster thing (especially since I think Chuck Taylors and glasses are fashionable by themselves), this is just too much. It’s like my fellow bloggers are drinking some kind of invisible Kool-Aid, rendering them unable to see the irony about hipsters that most of us can see. So I’m gonna rant about it. Here we go.

The most basic, yet accurate, description of a hipster that I can think of is this:

A hipster is someone that embraces individuality and the counter-culture; someone who does not feel the need to conform and who can stand tall in society, proudly bearing their personal tastes and beliefs for all to see.

Now, bear in mind that this is my description. And, since this is my blog, I have no obligation to ensure its congruency with the definitions of other people. (ha, just kidding – I’m not that arrogant. Maybe.) However, I like to be thorough. Therefore, I also offer up the top definition from Urban Dictionary, agreed upon by over 60,000 voters:

  • Hipsters are a subculture of men and women typically in their 20’s and 30’s that value independent thinking, counter-culture, progressive politics, an appreciation of art and indie-rock, creativity, intelligence, and witty banter. [read the rest]

Hmm… independent thinking, counter-culture, appreciation of art… yep, that pretty much meshes with my definition. Cool. So, going off of that, here are some pictures of people I would think could be labeled as “hipsters”:

Teddy

Teddy Roosevelt: While he was a Republican (through his presidency anyway), this guy was definitely politically progressive, perhaps illustrated best by his wild adventures in trust busting. He could even be thought of as one of the early proponents of “going green” with his advocacy of natural conservation. Independent thinker? Check. This guy read thousands of books during his lifetime and wrote more than 35 of his own. As an advocate of “the strenuous life”, he did crazy things like skinny dipping during winter and having singlestick bouts right before White House meetings. Yup, Teddy was definitely a hipster.

Lady Gaga

Lady Gaga: Most pop stars are content to travel a well-beaten path: use tired beats, dress the same as everyone before them, and gradually get skankier and skankier. Lady Gaga’s a little different. Ok, a lot different. Say what you want about her, but Gaga is one artist who’s unafraid to be be “weird”. Her integration of unorthodox fashion and art into her music says a lot about the way she thinks, and the fact that she’s still innovating after all her insane success is notable as well.

Martin Boehme

Martin Boehme: While not as famous as the last two, I still consider my good friend (and contributing writer around here) Martin to be a “hipster”. As a pasty white kid from Council Bluffs, Iowa who’s never been outside of Iowa and Nebraska, Martin’s independent nature has led him to become fluent in Spanish and semi-fluent in French, and get damn good at rapping. This guy cares about what people think of him just about as much as a honey badger cares: not at all. Why else would he buy a custom-made pair of pink jogging pants with Mel Gibson’s face on them? (by the way, they’re hilarious) Yep, Martin fits the definition of hipster pretty well.

I think we can all agree that the aforementioned people would be hipsters. The most convincing fact that will attest to this is that none of them have anything obvious in common. A huge part of being a hipster – at least by the definition that most people agree on – is emphasizing one’s individuality and not conforming to any norms, be they societal or of a subculture.

So why then do all the people who consider themselves to be hipsters invariably look something like this?

Stupid Hipster

Seriously. “Hipsters” generally base their (often publicly announced) title on the following criteria:

  • Liking stuff that’s ironic
  • Wearing glasses, even though they can see just fine
  • Shopping at Goodwill, but not to be frugal
  • Using Instagram for every picture (because vintage is always appropriate)
  • Listening to Neutral Milk Hotel and Janelle Monáe instead of Nickelback and Ke$ha (except they still listen to the latter two when nobody’s around to know about it)
  • Wearing Chuck Taylors

Other things that may not be universal to hipsters but that are common include:

  • Riding fixed-gear bikes
  • Having mustaches, even if they don’t have the face for it
  • Smelling bad
  • Drinking Pabst Blue Ribbon
  • Procreating in dumpsters
  • Thinking they’re better than you (ordering the vegan option)
  • Letting you know they’re better than you (calling attention to the fact that they’re ordering the vegan option)

A lof of these behaviors seem crazy, depraved, and downright stupid, but the fact remains that many people start doing them because they’ve somehow become part of this “subculture”. And, as more people do it, it becomes more popular. It’s almost as if a group of people started a cult with a bunch of set rules, and then named it by ironically hijacking a word with the complete opposite meaning (namely, there shouldn’t be rules or norms).

This guy explains the phenomenon quite better than I can:

So, basically the culture has deviated completely from the established definition of the word they use to label themselves. Because of this, I think it’s pretty dumb that some of my favorite college blogs are publishing all these articles about hipsters:

  • Oh, The Hipsters You’ll Meet In College – how can you possibly create subcategories in a culture that’s all about not being categorized?
  • How To Dress Like A Hipster – I honestly can’t think of anything more contradictory to the definition of “hipster” than a checklist on how to look like one. Seriously, if people are actually looking to guides like this for guidance, then I ought to just quit blogging and start selling a single t-shirt that says, “I Don’t Conform to Stuff, Bro” – I’d make a killing.

Even more confusing, however, is the existence of a hipster photo contest. The fact that a publication expects people to send in photos of themselves with the intent to convince other people that they fit a “hipster look” can only mean one of two things:

  • They don’t see the irony in it
  • They realize that their readers don’t see the irony and are capitalizing on it

I’m going to go with the second one. Now, as a capitalist, I can’t necessarily condemn them for creating a contest that exploits some students’ inability to see irony. However, if it’s really going to go this far, I really think we should redefine the word and leave the true independent thinkers in peace. Therefore, here’s what you get:

Hipster: someone whose wardrobe is a combination of Hot Topic and their grandparent’s closet, and who has been on the Internet more than most people.

There. That wraps up the fashion sense and obscure tastes quite nicely. The other things I’ll just relegate to stupidity (Pabst is crap and fixed-gear bikes are mechanically inferior).

So that’s my rant. If you don’t like it…

dealwithit

If you did like this article, clicking the Like button floating over at the left is appreciated.

Thomas Frank is the geek behind College Info Geek. After paying off $14K in student loans before graduating, landing jobs and internships, starting a successful business, and travelling the globe, he's now on a mission to help you build a remarkable college experience as well. Get the Newsletter | Twitter | Instagram

Hey there! Please note that some links in the article may be referral links, meaning that if you buy something through them, I'll earn a commission (at no extra cost to you). This helps to support CIG, but please don't buy anything unless you truly believe it'll benefit you! You can learn more here. Thank you :)

Want to Earn Better Grades?

Did you find this article useful?

Over 150,000 awesome students are learning how to dominate their classes, get more done, and land the jobs they want - and you should too.

Join in, and I'll also send you a free copy of my book on earning better grades!

// Read This Next

The Ultimate Guide To Building A Personal Website

Want more? Join over 150,000 students and grab my free book on earning better grades  →